111 510 510 libonline@riphah.edu.pk Contact

Who will judge the judges?

There is something surreal about those black-and-white, grainy photographs. Dazed, listless people being herded around and transported like cattle on trucks and trains to their imminent end as if in a trance. Watching those striking, searing images of a condemned people – fear and despair writ large on their faces – from the last century, I often wonder: How did the world let it happen?

An entire community is singled out and consigned to gas chambers, or worse, for the cardinal sin of being born as Jews. And the civilised world with its fine institutions could do little to stop one of the worst instances of mass extermination taking place right before its eyes. Not only did the world allow the Jewish Holocaust in all its horror to go on for years, it stood and stared when yesterday’s victims visited the same horror on the Palestinians soon after.

The stark, black-and-white photographs published by Indian Express this past week with its report about the absurd Delhi court verdict, acquitting all 16 accused cops in the 1987 Hashimpura massacre of 42 Muslims, eerily reminded one of those images from the Nazi era – Jews being herded around and carted off to Auschwitz.

Helpless, terrified young boys and old men – some of them in their shorts, vests and lungis – with their hands raised in surrender cowering as the brave guns of the Provincial Armed Constabulary pointed at them as if they were terrorists or wild, dangerous animals. And the same question popped in mind: How could this have happened in independent India with all its fine, democratic institutions and fiercely free media?

Interestingly, it’s not the right-wing BJP but the secular, liberal Congress, fabled for its ‘appeasement’ of Muslims; the party had been in power both in UP and in Delhi. But then what’s new? The majority of the 50,000 communal riots that have taken place in the country since Independence have happened on the Congress’s watch.

After a visit to Hashimpura in 1987, Nikhil Chakravarty, editor of ‘Mainstream,’ compared the massacre to “Nazi Pogrom against the Jews, to strike terror and nothing but terror in a whole minority community”.

The series of images, courageously captured for posterity by a little known photographer, Praveen Jain – defying threats to his own life – in Hashimpura, Meerut, tell their own story. These are ‘Photographs That Stand Witness’ to one of the most shameful crimes in the history of independent India. By the way, Meerut, barely 70 kilometres from Delhi, is the town where the first war of Independence began.

Delhi’s Tees Hazari court in its wisdom chose to ignore all this photographic, screaming evidence though. One could of course argue that photographs of men being rounded up by the PAC whose bullet-riddled bodies were later fished out of the upper Ganga canal did not prove anything.

However, a pile of other incriminating evidence against the killers in uniform, including the testimonies of four victims who survived the indiscriminate firing by the PAC men and were apparently left for dead, had been presented before the court. Bullet marks on the victims’ bodies and their first person accounts of how they were all detained in full view of the world, transported and shot before being dumped in the canal were not enough for the court.

Even the findings of the Central Bureau of Investigation, filed in a ‘confidential report’ in 1994, were not worth considering for the learned judge.

India’s premier investigating agency noted: “On 22nd May 1987 around 8pm, they herded 40-42 ‘rioters’ in PAC Truck No. UR 1493 at Hashimpura overtly for taking them to Meerut Civil Lines or Police Lines. However, the Platoon Commander S P Singh drove to the Upper Ganga Canal Muradnagar (Ghaziabad) ignoring their protests. On reaching there they started to unceremoniously shooting them down. When a few tried to escape they were shot down on the spot and their bodies were cast into the Canal. Rest of them were taken to the Hindon canal and there the sordid show was reenacted. ‘’

Yet the Delhi court chose to absolve the killers in khaki giving them the “benefit of doubt due to insufficient evidence, particularly on the identification of the accused”.

Coming as the verdict does after an interminable wait of 28 years and a long and hard struggle for justice, it’s a classic case of justice being both delayed and denied.

This after the long struggle by civil society groups to have the case moved to Delhi from UP where there was little hope of justice being delivered under the watchful eyes of successive state governments and security agencies. Now it seems justice will elude the dispossessed lot of this country whether it is UP, Delhi or Gujarat.

What is more disturbing is the general pattern courts in India seem to be increasingly following in such cases, letting the high and mighty get away with murder, literally. We have seen this happen in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh and elsewhere in the past few years.

The people who orchestrated mass murder and rapes, staged fake encounters, abused state institutions and brought shame and infamy to India have made it to parliament and the highest offices in the land, chiefly thanks to the failure or complicity of courts and law-enforcement agencies. Most of those convicted in Gujarat for some of the most heinous crimes against humanity are either free or out on bail.

For all its imperfections, India has enjoyed the world’s respect all these years because of its democratic institutions, independent media and judiciary. Even when the confidence of Indians – its disadvantaged groups and communities, in particular – in other arms of the state had been shaken at times, their faith in its courts endured. The judiciary remained the last hope.

Where do we go for justice and recourse when courts cave in to the pulls and pressures of the powerful and the corrupt? What hope is left for the vulnerable and dispossessed sections of society when the law enforcers turn its worst violators and judges allow their sense of justice and reason to be clouded by considerations of clan and community?

Where will the truth go to hide when you look at it and pretend it does not exist? In the words of Sophocles, how dreadful it is when the right judge judges wrong! Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes? Who will guard the guards? Who will judge the judges? How can we claim to be the world’s greatest democracy when the weakest and voiceless amongst us are perpetually under siege?

Freedom, democracy, liberty, equality…these are mere words, unless they are backed by justice. Justice consists not in being neutral between right and wrong but standing up for those who have been wronged.

In the end, as Aristotle would reason, it is in justice that the ordering of society is centred. Without justice and equity, all is lost. In the acquittal of the PAC killers, as a lawyer of the victims put it, it is not the people of Hashimpura who have lost. This is a setback for Indian democracy and all that it stands for.

Since Modi rode to power in Delhi promising ‘acche din,’ not a day has passed without the nation’s minorities experiencing the good times. From vandalising churches, mosques and schools to the daily war of words against minorities, the project to paint India saffron has gone full steam. A brazen Subramanian Swamy decrees that mosques and churches are not places of worship and hence fair game for mobs.

Another Hindutva luminary defends the rape of a 71-year-old nun inside a convent in the name of a ‘sexual culture’ that Christianity apparently espouses. And if RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat is to be believed, Mother Teresa, who spent all her life serving the rejected lot of Indian society, had indeed been on a proselytising mission.

Now Bhagwat doesn’t speak for an extremist fringe. As the supreme guide of the Parivar including that of the prime minister, he represents the mainstream. This is what is most worrying. This is why there’s a method in the madness being unleashed across the country. Where, in God’s name, are we headed as a country? Have we learnt no lessons from our own history?

The writer is a Middle East based columnist.

Email: aijaz.syed@hotmail.com

Aijaz Zaka Syed, "Who will judge the judges?," The News. 2015-03-27.
Keywords: Social sciences , Social issues , Social system , Political issues , Poverty-India , Human rights , Social evils , Society-India , Violation-Law , Social Crimes , Degradation society , India